Write a response in which you argue what success really means.

Assignment Question

Write a response in which you argue what success really means. What does it mean to “win”? What are the benefits of winning? What are the costs? Write a clear, arguable thesis and use evidence from at least two texts in the unit to support your argument. You may also draw on relevant personal experiences to support your ideas. Remember to include the following in your argumentative essay: an introduction a thesis statement coherent body paragraphs supporting evidence and original commentary a counter argument, concession, and rebuttal rhetorical devices a conclusion When writing, it is important to consider your audience and purpose so you can write appropriately for them. Your audience consists of your teacher and peers, and your purpose is implied within the writing prompt. Reread the prompt to determine your purpose for writing. To begin, review the questions below and then select a strategy, such as brainstorming, journaling, reading, or discussing, to generate ideas. After generating ideas, begin the prewriting process by writing a summary of your writing plan. In your summary, respond to the following questions: Purpose: What does it mean to win? How do the texts support your argument? Audience: Who is your audience? How do you want them to view the texts differently? Introduction: How will you introduce the topic and thesis of your essay? Do your topic and thesis present a unique perspective on the texts? Thesis Statement: What is your claim about the topic or issue? How can you word your claim so it is clear to readers? Evidence: What evidence will you use to support your claim? What facts, details, examples, and quotations will convince your audience to agree with your claim? Rhetorical Devices: What kinds of techniques and language will you use to persuade your audience? How can you appeal to your audience’s logic, emotions, and ethics? Transitions: How will you smoothly transition from one idea to another within and across paragraphs? Conclusion: How will you wrap up your argument? How can you restate the main ideas in your argument without being redundant? Response Use the questions in the bulleted list to write a one-paragraph summary. Your summary should describe what you will argue in your argumentative essay like the one above. Don’t worry about including all of the details now; focus only on the most essential and important elements. You will refer back to this short summary as you continue through the steps of the writing process. If you achieve what you want to and are happy, then I think that is a success. It could be applied to life in general or to individual tasks in life. My definition of success is achieving personal goals, whatever they may be. Rhetorical Devices that i’ll probably use are logic and emotions. The two texts I’ll probably use will be Fences and Texas Tiny Homes. other texts I can use are Test: “The Night Before Christmas” by Tomas Rivera letter from Chief Ross 3,822 miles by rick bass the cactus by O.Herry “It Ain’t Bragging If It’s True: The Tale of Texas Literature” by J. Scott Brownlee



What does it truly mean to “win” in life? Is success solely measured by the attainment of personal goals, or does it encompass a more nuanced definition? In this essay, we will explore the multifaceted nature of success and examine its benefits and costs. Drawing from August Wilson’s play “Fences” and the case of “Texas Tiny Homes,” we will argue that success should be viewed as a holistic journey rather than a mere outcome. While winning can bring rewards, it is essential to recognize that success encompasses more than just victory, and its true value lies in the personal growth and fulfillment it provides. Success is not confined to the act of winning but is better defined as the realization of personal goals and the growth and fulfillment achieved through the pursuit of those goals. By considering this broader perspective, we can appreciate the multifaceted nature of success and its profound impact on individuals.

The Complexity of Success in “Fences”

In August Wilson’s renowned play, “Fences,” the character of Troy Maxson provides a compelling illustration of the multifaceted nature of success. Troy’s life is far from the conventional notion of “winning.” Born into a racially segregated society, Troy faces formidable barriers and personal hardships throughout his life. He grapples with the legacy of racial discrimination and economic inequality, which have limited his opportunities and aspirations. Despite these challenges, Troy embarks on a journey that transcends mere victory, offering profound insights into the essence of success (Wilson, 1985).

One of the central themes in “Fences” is the pursuit of the American Dream, a symbol of success often associated with material wealth and prosperity. Troy aspires to own his home and provide for his family, which aligns with this traditional view of success. However, as the narrative unfolds, it becomes clear that Troy’s success is not confined to financial achievements. His relentless dedication to working and providing for his family, albeit through a menial job, demonstrates his unwavering commitment to personal goals (Wilson, 1985).

Moreover, Troy’s success extends beyond the realm of tangible rewards. It lies in the lessons he imparts to his son Cory and the impact he leaves on those around him. Despite his own experiences of racial injustice and dashed dreams, Troy imparts valuable life lessons to Cory about the importance of hard work and resilience. In this sense, success is not measured by wealth but by the wisdom and values he imparts to the next generation (Wilson, 1985).

Troy’s character also highlights the significance of personal growth as an integral component of success. Throughout the play, we witness his transformation from a young, ambitious baseball player with unfulfilled dreams to a mature, responsible father and husband. His success is evident in his ability to adapt and grow, even in the face of adversity. This personal growth, fueled by his experiences and choices, underscores that success is a dynamic and evolving concept that encompasses more than just external achievements (Wilson, 1985).

In “Fences,” August Wilson invites us to rethink success as a multifaceted concept that goes beyond conventional notions of winning. Troy Maxson’s life journey illustrates that success is deeply intertwined with personal goals, resilience, and the legacy one leaves behind. While Troy may not have won in the traditional sense, his story teaches us that success is not solely measured by material wealth or fame but by the depth of personal growth and the meaningful impact we make on the lives of others (Wilson, 1985).

This perspective challenges us to reconsider our own definitions of success, emphasizing the importance of personal growth, perseverance, and the lasting influence we have on the world around us. Troy Maxson’s complex character in “Fences” serves as a powerful reminder that success is a nuanced and profound journey, with lessons that extend far beyond the final score.

Reimagining Success Through “Texas Tiny Homes”

In the case of “Texas Tiny Homes,” the story of this venture offers an intriguing perspective on success that extends beyond conventional notions of winning or financial gain. Founded by Brad Kittel, “Texas Tiny Homes” represents a unique approach to the housing industry, with a focus on sustainable living and providing affordable housing solutions (Texas Tiny Homes, 2020).

Purpose-Driven Success

Brad Kittel’s journey with “Texas Tiny Homes” underscores that success is deeply rooted in purpose and the positive impact one can have on the world. Rather than pursuing profit as the sole measure of success, Kittel is driven by a passion for sustainable living and addressing the housing crisis. His commitment to constructing tiny, energy-efficient houses reflects a broader vision that extends beyond financial gains (Texas Tiny Homes, 2020).

While the venture aims to build and sell tiny houses, the true success of “Texas Tiny Homes” lies in its commitment to sustainability and affordability. Kittel’s decision to prioritize eco-friendly building materials, energy-efficient systems, and small, functional designs aligns with his personal values and larger societal goals. By focusing on providing affordable housing solutions, Kittel has made a significant contribution to addressing a pressing social issue, further emphasizing that success should be defined by the positive impact one has on society (Texas Tiny Homes, 2020).

Measuring Success Beyond Profit

It is important to note that the success of “Texas Tiny Homes” cannot be solely measured by financial profit. While the venture may generate revenue, its true value lies in the potential to revolutionize the housing industry, reduce the environmental footprint, and offer affordable housing solutions to those in need. Kittel’s commitment to these goals demonstrates that success encompasses more than just economic gains (Texas Tiny Homes, 2020).

Moreover, the impact of “Texas Tiny Homes” extends beyond the immediate customers who purchase their tiny houses. By promoting sustainable living practices and offering an alternative to traditional housing, the venture contributes to a broader cultural shift toward more eco-conscious and affordable living. This ripple effect underscores that success is not confined to individual achievements but can inspire societal change (Texas Tiny Homes, 2020).

The story of “Texas Tiny Homes” challenges conventional notions of success by highlighting the importance of purpose-driven endeavors and their potential to create a positive impact on society. Brad Kittel’s dedication to sustainable living and affordable housing solutions emphasizes that success should not be narrowly defined by profit but should encompass a larger vision of making the world a better place. This perspective encourages us to reevaluate our own definitions of success, considering the broader implications of our actions and the positive influence we can have on the world.

The Costs and Sacrifices of Success

While the pursuit of success can yield numerous benefits, it is essential to acknowledge that it often comes with its own set of costs and sacrifices. These costs, however, should be viewed as investments in personal growth and the realization of meaningful goals (Wilson, 1985).

Investing Time and Effort

One of the most significant costs associated with the pursuit of success is the investment of time and effort. Achieving success typically requires dedication, hard work, and perseverance. Whether it’s building a business like “Texas Tiny Homes” or striving for personal excellence, individuals must commit substantial time and energy to their goals (Texas Tiny Homes, 2020).

For example, Brad Kittel, the founder of “Texas Tiny Homes,” dedicated years of his life to developing his vision. His commitment to sustainable living and affordable housing solutions required extensive research, planning, and hands-on work. The time and effort invested in his venture were substantial, but they ultimately led to the realization of his goals and the positive impact of his work on society (Texas Tiny Homes, 2020).

Sacrificing Personal Relationships

Another significant cost of pursuing success is the potential sacrifice of personal relationships. The demands of ambitious goals can strain personal and family relationships. Long hours, travel, and the mental and emotional toll of pursuing one’s dreams can sometimes lead to strained relationships with loved ones (Wilson, 1985).

In “Fences,” Troy Maxson’s pursuit of his personal goals, including providing for his family, strains his relationship with his son, Cory. Troy’s determination to impart his values of hard work and resilience comes at the cost of a strained father-son relationship. However, it is essential to note that these sacrifices are made in the pursuit of success and, in some cases, may lead to personal growth and the achievement of meaningful goals (Wilson, 1985).

Balancing Costs and Rewards

While the pursuit of success may involve costs and sacrifices, it is crucial to recognize that these investments can lead to significant rewards. Personal growth, the realization of meaningful goals, and the positive impact on society are among the potential rewards of success (Texas Tiny Homes, 2020).

Moreover, individuals who are deeply committed to their goals often find personal fulfillment and a sense of purpose in their pursuits. The satisfaction that comes from overcoming challenges and achieving what one set out to accomplish can outweigh the costs incurred along the way. Ultimately, the rewards of success extend beyond material gains and can enrich one’s life in profound ways (Wilson, 1985).

The pursuit of success often involves costs and sacrifices, such as the investment of time and effort and potential strain on personal relationships. However, these sacrifices should be viewed as investments in personal growth and the realization of meaningful goals. The rewards of success, including personal fulfillment and a positive impact on society, can outweigh the costs incurred in the journey toward achieving one’s aspirations (Texas Tiny Homes, 2020).

Counterargument: Narrow Definition of Success

Some may argue that success is primarily about winning competitions, accumulating wealth, or achieving fame. This perspective maintains that tangible achievements and external recognition are the sole indicators of success, and any other definition is overly idealistic or impractical. According to this view, individuals who have not amassed substantial wealth or secured widespread recognition cannot be considered successful (Wilson, 1985).

Rebuttal: Embracing Diverse Aspirations and Values

However, this narrow view neglects the diverse aspirations and values that drive individuals. As demonstrated through the examples of Troy Maxson in “Fences” and Brad Kittel with “Texas Tiny Homes,” success is not a one-size-fits-all concept. People have unique goals, passions, and values that guide their journeys. Success is deeply personal and can be defined by the pursuit of these individual aspirations, even if they do not align with traditional measures of wealth or fame (Wilson, 1985; Texas Tiny Homes, 2020).

Moreover, it is essential to recognize that society benefits from a wide range of definitions of success. Not everyone can or should strive for the same external markers of achievement. Embracing diverse definitions of success fosters creativity, innovation, and a rich tapestry of contributions to society. The notion that success can only be defined by wealth or fame is limiting and fails to acknowledge the meaningful impact individuals can make in their own unique ways (Wilson, 1985; Texas Tiny Homes, 2020).

While some may argue for a narrow definition of success tied exclusively to external markers of achievement, this view overlooks the diverse aspirations and values that guide individuals. The examples of Troy Maxson and Brad Kittel demonstrate that success is deeply personal and can encompass a wide range of goals and contributions. Embracing diverse definitions of success enriches society and allows individuals to find fulfillment in their unique journeys.


In conclusion, success is not confined to the simplistic notion of winning; it is a multifaceted concept encompassing personal growth, fulfillment, and the achievement of meaningful goals. Drawing from “Fences” and the story of “Texas Tiny Homes,” we have seen that success is deeply tied to purpose and the positive impact one has on the world. While the pursuit of success may involve sacrifices, the rewards are far-reaching, shaping not only individual lives but also society as a whole. To truly understand success, we must embrace its complexity and acknowledge that it is not just about “winning” but about becoming the best version of ourselves.


Texas Tiny Homes. (2020). About Us.

Wilson, A. (1985). Fences. Samuel French, Inc.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

  1. What is the primary argument in this essay?
    • The primary argument in this essay is that success should not be narrowly defined as winning but rather as the realization of personal goals, personal growth, and the fulfillment achieved through pursuing those goals.
  2. What texts are used as evidence in this essay, and how do they support the argument?
    • The essay draws evidence from August Wilson’s “Fences” to illustrate that success encompasses personal growth and legacy. Additionally, the case of “Texas Tiny Homes” demonstrates that success extends beyond financial gains, emphasizing the importance of purpose and societal impact.
  3. What are the benefits of success, as discussed in the essay?
    • The benefits of success include personal fulfillment, a sense of accomplishment, and the positive impact one can have on society. Success is portrayed as a holistic journey that goes beyond material rewards.
  4. Are there any costs associated with the pursuit of success, and how are they addressed in the essay?
    • Yes, the essay acknowledges that the pursuit of success may involve sacrifices, such as time and effort, and potentially personal relationships. However, it argues that these costs should be viewed as investments in personal growth and the realization of meaningful goals.
  5. How does the essay address counterarguments?
    • The essay acknowledges the counterargument that success is solely about winning competitions, accumulating wealth, or achieving fame. It counters this perspective by emphasizing that success is a diverse and complex concept tied to individual aspirations and values.