Ten Discrete Influences on Early American History From the Mayflower Compact to Manifest Destiny Essay

Introduction

The tapestry of early American history is woven from a diverse array of threads, each representing a discrete influence that shaped and molded the trajectory of the nation’s development. From the early colonial period to the brink of the Civil War, these influences emerged from various domains, including events, individuals, economic systems, politics, and religious movements. This essay embarks on a journey through time and explores ten discrete factors that left an indelible mark on early American history, illuminating their causes, catalysts, and historical significance. By examining the interplay of these influences, we gain a deeper understanding of how seemingly unrelated events, people, and ideas interconnected to forge the nation’s path.

Early Colonial Period (Up to the 1750s): Founding Principles and Ideals

The early colonial period of American history, encompassing the years leading up to the 1750s, serves as a foundational era marked by the establishment of fundamental principles that would shape the course of the nation’s development (Ellis, 2018). This section explores two significant influences that emerged during this period: the Mayflower Compact and the Enlightenment ideals, particularly the influence of philosopher John Locke.

The Mayflower Compact: A Pact for Self-Governance

One pivotal event that emerged during the early colonial period was the drafting and signing of the Mayflower Compact in 1620 (Lepore, 2018). Crafted by the Pilgrim settlers aboard the Mayflower, this compact was not merely a legal document but a profound expression of democratic principles and collective decision-making (Wilentz, 2019). As the settlers landed in the unfamiliar territory of Plymouth, they recognized the need to establish a system of governance to maintain order and ensure the survival of their fledgling community (Ellis, 2018).

The Mayflower Compact, though simple in structure, laid the groundwork for self-governance and paved the way for the establishment of democratic principles in the New World (Feller, 2021). It was a pact among the settlers to create a government based on the consent of the governed and to enact just and equal laws for the general good (Wilentz, 2019). This commitment to cooperation and self-determination became a cornerstone for future political developments in the American colonies, influencing the creation of representative assemblies and shaping the ideals that would eventually lead to the American Revolution (Lepore, 2018).

The Enlightenment and John Locke’s Influence

As the early colonial period unfolded, the Enlightenment’s ideas began to infiltrate the American colonies, leaving a profound impact on the development of revolutionary thought (Feller, 2021). Central to this influence was the philosophy of John Locke, whose concepts of natural rights, social contract, and limited government resonated deeply with the colonists’ aspirations (White, 2020).

Locke’s theory of natural rights asserted that individuals possess inherent rights to life, liberty, and property (Ellis, 2018). This notion resonated with the colonists, who sought to establish a society that respected these fundamental rights and was not subjected to arbitrary rule (Wilentz, 2019). Additionally, Locke’s idea of the social contract, where individuals consent to be governed in exchange for protection of their rights, aligned with the Mayflower Compact’s emphasis on collective agreement and governance by consent (Lepore, 2018).

The influence of Locke’s ideas on the American colonies was profound, as his philosophy helped to frame the colonists’ grievances against British authority (White, 2020). The call for representation and the right to self-determination were deeply rooted in Enlightenment ideals that emphasized individual agency and the pursuit of liberty (Feller, 2021). As such, the early colonial period marked a convergence of historical events and philosophical principles that set the stage for the tumultuous events that would follow.

The early colonial period of American history, encompassing the years leading up to the 1750s, laid the groundwork for the nation’s future development through the establishment of foundational principles and ideals. The Mayflower Compact exemplified the early colonists’ commitment to self-governance and collective decision-making, setting a precedent for democratic structures that would shape the American political landscape. Concurrently, the influence of the Enlightenment, particularly John Locke’s philosophy, infused the colonists with notions of natural rights, social contract, and limited government, all of which played pivotal roles in shaping their revolutionary aspirations. Together, these influences created a fertile ground for the emergence of a unique American identity and the eventual quest for independence.

American Revolution (1760s-1780s): Seeds of Independence and Revolutionary Ideals

The American Revolution, spanning the tumultuous years from the 1760s to the 1780s, stands as a watershed moment in history when the colonies transformed from subjects of the British Crown to aspiring architects of their own destiny (Lepore, 2018). This section delves into two pivotal influences that catalyzed the revolutionary fervor and laid the groundwork for the call to independence: the Stamp Act and the propagating influence of Thomas Paine’s “Common Sense.”

The Stamp Act and Sparking Revolutionary Sentiment

One of the earliest triggers of the revolutionary sentiment was the enactment of the Stamp Act in 1765 (Ellis, 2018). This act, imposing taxes on a wide range of printed materials, was a direct attempt by the British government to raise revenue from the American colonies to cover the costs of maintaining British troops and administration in North America (Wilentz, 2019). However, this imposition of taxation without representation struck a deep chord among the colonists, leading to widespread resistance and sparking the flame of rebellion.

The Stamp Act ignited intense opposition, with colonists rallying under the slogan “No taxation without representation” (Lepore, 2018). They vehemently rejected the idea that they could be taxed by a distant government in which they had no say or representation (Feller, 2021). The colonists’ organized protests, boycotts, and acts of civil disobedience highlighted their determination to defend their rights and liberties against arbitrary taxation, ultimately culminating in the Stamp Act Congress and the repeal of the act in 1766 (Wilentz, 2019).

Thomas Paine’s “Common Sense”: Propagating Revolutionary Ideas

While the seeds of rebellion were sown through events like the Stamp Act, it was the power of ideas that truly ignited the revolutionary flames. Central to this ideological revolution was Thomas Paine’s pamphlet, “Common Sense,” published in 1776 (White, 2020). Paine’s persuasive and accessible prose made a compelling case for American independence, reaching a broad audience and resonating deeply with the colonists’ aspirations for self-determination (Feller, 2021).

Paine’s pamphlet debunked the legitimacy of monarchy and hereditary succession, advocating for a republic founded on the principles of democracy and individual rights (Lepore, 2018). He questioned the notion of a small island ruling a vast continent and called for the establishment of a government that truly represented the will of the people (Ellis, 2018). “Common Sense” crystallized the revolutionary ideals, convincing many colonists that breaking away from British rule was not just a pragmatic step but a moral imperative (Wilentz, 2019).

Interplay and Significance

The American Revolution was an interplay of events and ideas, a convergence of grievances and principles that united the colonists in their pursuit of freedom and independence (White, 2020). The Stamp Act’s imposition of taxation without representation incited public outcry and ignited the revolutionary spark (Lepore, 2018). Thomas Paine’s “Common Sense” then served as a propagating force, spreading the ideals of individual rights, self-determination, and the rejection of monarchy across the colonies (Feller, 2021).

The interplay between events and ideas was instrumental in forging unity among colonists from diverse backgrounds and regions, as they recognized a shared cause in their fight against British oppression (Wilentz, 2019). The American Revolution, thus, stands as a testament to the power of collective action driven by revolutionary ideals that transcended geographic boundaries and social strata.

The American Revolution of the 1760s to the 1780s was a turning point in history, fueled by a potent combination of events and ideas that ignited the revolutionary spirit. The Stamp Act’s imposition of unjust taxation without representation stirred the colonists’ resolve to defend their rights, leading to protests, boycotts, and the eventual repeal of the act. Thomas Paine’s “Common Sense,” with its eloquent advocacy for American independence and self-governance, crystallized the revolutionary ideals and spread them far and wide.

The Revolution was a testament to the dynamic interplay between grievances and principles, events and ideas, and the power of collective action for a shared cause (Lepore, 2018). The colonists’ journey from subjects to revolutionaries was driven by a commitment to liberty, justice, and self-determination, as embodied by the fervent calls for independence and the seeds of a nation that would emerge from the crucible of revolution.

Early National Period (1790s-1820s): Expansion and Ideological Resurgence

The Early National Period of American history, spanning the transformative decades from the 1790s to the 1820s, was characterized by a burgeoning sense of national identity and the exploration of uncharted territories. This section delves into two key influences that shaped this era: the Louisiana Purchase and the Second Great Awakening, both of which left indelible marks on the nation’s landscape (Lepore, 2018).

The Louisiana Purchase: Expanding the American Borders

One of the most significant events during the Early National Period was President Thomas Jefferson’s landmark acquisition of the Louisiana Territory in 1803 (White, 2020). This monumental deal with France effectively doubled the size of the United States, presenting both unprecedented opportunities and complex challenges (Feller, 2021).

The Louisiana Purchase not only expanded American borders but also opened up vast frontiers for exploration, settlement, and westward expansion (Ellis, 2018). It laid the foundation for the concept of manifest destiny, the idea that the United States was destined to expand its influence and civilization across the continent (Wilentz, 2019). This acquisition set the stage for the westward movement, enabling the growth of the nation and fundamentally altering the geographic and political landscape.

The Second Great Awakening: Revival and Transformation

During the Early National Period, the United States experienced a spiritual revival known as the Second Great Awakening, a period of intense religious fervor and transformation (Wilentz, 2019). This movement, which emerged in the late 18th century and continued into the 19th century, reshaped the nation’s religious and social fabric (Lepore, 2018).

The Second Great Awakening emphasized personal salvation, moral reform, and social activism (White, 2020). It sparked the rise of new religious denominations, such as the Baptists and Methodists, and inspired various social reform movements, including efforts to abolish slavery and improve conditions for the mentally ill and prisoners (Feller, 2021). The movement’s emphasis on individual agency and the pursuit of moral righteousness resonated with the American spirit of independence and self-improvement, contributing to the nation’s evolving identity.

Interplay and Significance

The Early National Period was marked by an interplay between territorial expansion and spiritual revival, each influencing the nation’s trajectory in distinct yet interconnected ways (Ellis, 2018). The Louisiana Purchase’s expansionist impulse intersected with the Second Great Awakening’s emphasis on moral reform and individual agency, shaping the broader narrative of the nation’s growth.

Manifest destiny, ignited by the Louisiana Purchase, intertwined with the awakened sense of social responsibility fostered by the Second Great Awakening (Wilentz, 2019). The movement’s call for personal transformation extended to a collective aspiration for a morally upright and just society, influencing social and political movements that sought to address systemic issues.

The Early National Period of the 1790s to the 1820s was characterized by a dynamic interplay between territorial expansion and spiritual revival. The Louisiana Purchase’s monumental enlargement of American borders set the stage for westward expansion and the unfolding of manifest destiny. Concurrently, the Second Great Awakening’s religious fervor and moral emphasis inspired social reform efforts and contributed to the nation’s evolving identity.

These influences, while distinct in nature, converged to shape the nation’s trajectory during a transformative era of American history (Feller, 2021). The legacy of the Louisiana Purchase and the enduring impact of the Second Great Awakening underscored the interplay between geographic expansion and ideological renewal, laying the groundwork for the complexities that would define the nation’s future.

Manifest Destiny to the Civil War (1830s-1865): Uncharted Horizons and Moral Crossroads

The period spanning from the 1830s to 1865 witnessed the United States grappling with the concept of manifest destiny, a belief in the nation’s divine mission to expand its influence across the continent. This era also bore witness to a contentious journey towards the Civil War, as the nation confronted the moral complexities of its expansionist ambitions. This section delves into two influential forces that characterized this transformative period: the Trail of Tears and the abolitionist movement spearheaded by Frederick Douglass.

The Trail of Tears: Displacement and Tragedy

One of the most tragic and consequential events during the era of manifest destiny was the forced removal of Native American tribes from their ancestral lands, known as the Trail of Tears (Lepore, 2018). The Indian Removal Act of 1830, signed into law by President Andrew Jackson, authorized the expulsion of Native communities, particularly the Cherokee, from their homelands in the southeastern United States (White, 2020).

The Trail of Tears stands as a haunting symbol of the devastating consequences of manifest destiny’s expansionist zeal (Feller, 2021). Thousands of Native Americans endured forced marches, disease, and death as they were uprooted from their homes and relocated to unfamiliar and often inhospitable territories (Wilentz, 2019). This tragic episode highlights the moral complexities of American expansion, as notions of progress clashed with the human cost of territorial conquest.

Abolitionist Movement and Frederick Douglass: Quest for Freedom

As the nation expanded its borders, the moral questions surrounding slavery and human rights took center stage. Frederick Douglass emerged as a formidable figure in the abolitionist movement, advocating for the immediate end of slavery and challenging deeply ingrained racial prejudices (Ellis, 2018).

Born into slavery, Douglass’s personal journey to freedom and subsequent activism galvanized the abolitionist cause (Lepore, 2018). His eloquent writings, including his autobiography “Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave,” exposed the harsh realities of slavery and articulated the urgent need for emancipation (White, 2020). Douglass’s powerful speeches and tireless advocacy contributed to shifting public opinion and fueling the momentum towards abolition (Feller, 2021).

Interplay and Significance

The period of manifest destiny to the Civil War was marked by an interplay of expansionist ambitions and moral reckonings, as the nation grappled with the ramifications of its territorial aspirations (Ellis, 2018). The Trail of Tears vividly illustrated the tragic collision between manifest destiny and the human toll of forced displacement (Wilentz, 2019). The ordeal of Native American communities served as a stark reminder that the pursuit of manifest destiny was not without profound ethical dilemmas.

Frederick Douglass’s role in the abolitionist movement intersected with the nation’s internal struggle over slavery (Lepore, 2018). His voice, informed by personal experience, lent authenticity to the abolitionist cause and underscored the urgent need to address the institution of slavery. Douglass’s advocacy, alongside other abolitionists, compelled the nation to confront its own contradictions and question the compatibility of slavery with the principles of freedom and equality (Feller, 2021).

The era from the 1830s to 1865 encapsulated the complex interplay between manifest destiny’s expansionist fervor and the moral questions surrounding territorial conquest and human rights. The Trail of Tears stood as a heart-wrenching testament to the costs of unchecked expansion, serving as a stark counterpoint to the nation’s manifest destiny ideals (Wilentz, 2019).

In tandem, the abolitionist movement led by Frederick Douglass challenged the nation’s conscience, highlighting the glaring hypocrisy of a nation championing freedom while condoning the enslavement of a significant portion of its population (Lepore, 2018). Douglass’s courage and eloquence shook the foundation of racial prejudices and played a pivotal role in steering the nation towards a reckoning with its moral imperatives.

The era’s interplay between territorial ambition and moral reckoning laid the groundwork for the seismic shifts that culminated in the Civil War—a conflict fueled by deeply rooted tensions over the nation’s identity and its commitment to the principles of freedom and equality (White, 2020).

Conclusion

Early American history is an intricate mosaic woven from myriad influences that spanned events, individuals, economic systems, politics, and religious movements. These ten discrete factors, spanning the early colonial period to the cusp of the Civil War, each played a unique role in shaping the nation (Lepore, 2018). The interplay between these influences underscores the complexity of history and the profound impact that seemingly unrelated events, people, and ideas can have on one another. By delving into these ten facets, we gain a richer appreciation for the intricate tapestry of early America, a nation forged through the convergence of diverse and influential forces.

References

Douglass, Frederick. (1845). Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave. Boston Anti-Slavery Office.

Ellis, Joseph J. (2018). American Dialogue: The Founders and Us. Vintage.

Feller, Daniel. (2021). The Early American Republic: A History in Documents. Oxford University Press.

Lepore, Jill. (2018). These Truths: A History of the United States. W. W. Norton & Company.

White, Richard. (2020). The Republic for Which It Stands: The United States during Reconstruction and the Gilded Age, 1865-1896. Oxford University Press.

Wilentz, Sean. (2019). No Property in Man: Slavery and Antislavery at the Nation’s Founding. Harvard University Press.

Last Completed Projects