Why is this topic important, and who is the audience at CHI that would find this work influential and/or compelling?

Please pick one of the two papers to write your reviews.
Your reviews have to include the following:
a brief summary of the papers’ a) motivation, b) research gap, c) method, and d) findings (20/100);
the pros and cons of this research paper, e.g., the importance of the problem, the novelty of the contributions, etc. (15/100); – Please try to point out at least 2 pros and 2 cons
the rationale that supports your above critiques (40/100);
your approaches to addressing any limitations of the work (15/100);
implications of this work for future research or for your work (10/100).
*Please submit: 1) < 1000 words, and 2) a well-structured and clear critique. *Please do not copy and paste the paper's content and ideas. Try to compose your own statements. *You can either agree or disagree with the authors' opinions. We look forward to reading your own ideas. You can refer to the reference from CHI (an HCI top-tier conference) below to help you evaluate a research paper. Other references (Suggestions for CHI reviewers): Significance of the work: Please briefly summarize the problem, question, or design space that this submission addresses. Why is this topic important, and who is the audience at CHI that would find this work influential and/or compelling? Originality of the Contribution: Please assess how novel/original the contribution is and whether it builds on existing work in the area. Authors have only five days to improve their submission for the camera-ready deadline. Please suggest small and concrete edits that the author(s) can make to clarify their contribution. Validity of the method: Taking into account the type of contribution this work is making, please evaluate how well the submission addresses the question, problem, or design space presented by the authors. How well are the chosen methods described and justified within the submission? Written Presentation: Please assess whether the writing of the work is clear, understandable, and targeted for CHI. Please suggest any small and concrete edits that the author can make to clarify their writing.

Last Completed Projects