Reflect on criticism of “Formation”

Part Two Directions- Reflect on criticism of “Formation”
– Please read ONE of the attached opinion pieces about Beyoncé’s video for “Formation”. Then write at least three paragraphs, in MLA format, where you:
1) Give the title, author, and describe the main argument of that opinion piece (one paragraph or more).
2) Present at least one quote from the opinion piece and describe whether you think it provides strong or weak support for their argument. Use a quote sandwich, with MLA citations for the criticism piece and for the video; see attached file below for help with citations.
Sample in-text citation: “….”(Lewis).
Sample signal phrase: As Lewis claims, “….”
3) Then describe your own response to that point. Based on your evaluation of the video, do you agree or disagree with this point from the opinion piece? You can also describe whether you agree/disagree/partially agree with the overall argument in the opinion piece, if you choose to. Remember to refer to specific images from the video to support your analysis. You can refer to the lyrics if you choose to, but primarily you are trying to analyze the visual elements of Beyonce’s video.
4) Upload this entire reflection (description of opinion piece, quote and analysis of opinion piece, your response to the opinion piece on that point you just discussed)

Opinion Pieces
a) Analysis of visual elements/symbolism in “Formation” – read this for a mostly positive opinion on different groups that one filmmaker sees represented in the video, including New Orleans residents and queer folk/queer culture of New Orleans, and Black Lives Matter imagery.Cite this article by using the article title in quotation marks; this is the MLA rule that applies for a source like this that does not have an author listed. This is from a website, so you won’t use a page number in your citation.
http://www.npr.org/2016/02/08/466036710/beyonces-formation-is-a-visual-anthem.
b) “Formation” as affirmation of Southern Blackness/ Southern Black women – read this for a discussion of how Beyonce represents herself as a Southern Black woman, and how she represents Southern Black woman/female-identified folk in the video; this discussion includes the imagery and some lyrics. Cite this article by using the author’s last name. This is from a website, so you won’t use a page number in your citation.
http://www.theroot.com/beyonce-drops-formation-for-the-people-the-black-peo-1790854153.
c) “Formation” exploits New Orleans’ trauma – read this for more depth on specific New Orleans imagery featured in the video, including a discussion of the women wearing white dresses in the plantation house; this author has a very harsh opinion of the video. Cite this article by using the author’s last name. This is from a website, so you won’t use a page number in your citation.
http://www.slate.com/articles/double_x/doublex/2016/02/beyonc_s_formation_exploits_new_orleans_trauma.html

Last Completed Projects