The Topic is about the Revolution of Physics on the 20th Century. There are many examples but don’t forget to include the most important, like Relativity Theory and Quantum mechanics.
The theory of relativity
The principle of uncertainty
The challenge to the Newtonian view of the universe
The concept of relative motion
The idea that space and time are relative to the observer
The implications of the uncertainty principle for the behavior of particles on a quantum level
The development of quantum mechanics
The rejection of determinism and predictability in the physical world
The experimental confirmation of the theory of relativity
The impact of these ideas on our understanding of the universe and the laws of physics.
The research term paper will be over a topic of interest, with the approval of the instructor, in the history and philosophy of science. It will be a formal, scholarly work consistent in style and form to published scientific papers. It is intended to give you, as seniors in a scientific discipline, experience in preparing a formal scientific paper, to define and research a particular topic in your field, and to develop skills in analysis and critical thinking of bibliographic sources, data, and other information. The paper should be typed, double-spaced, taking care to avoid grammatical and typographical errors, and following the usual rules of a formal paper. In this course historically the typical length of these papers is 12-14 pages (meaning the body of the paper, not counting the title page, abstract, literature cited, and any figures you wish to include), so there is your target.
HOW YOUR PAPER LIKELY WILL BE STRUCTURED
The research papers in this class will likely have some important differences from the standard “humanities” paper with which you are most likely familiar. As science papers go, yours will most likely be of a standard scientific review paper that involves mostly “library” rather than experimental research. Organize the body of your paper to suit your own topic best, but at minimum, yours had better contain the following parts:
TITLE
The title identifies, in a concise phrase, the subject and important contents of the paper. A good title is thus critical to informing the reader what the paper is about. To help you focus your ideas on the subject, we recommend that you devise a working title as soon as you select a topic; you may revise it as necessary as you proceed. The critical criteria of a good title in a scientific paper are that it is informative and specific. Avoid vague or cutesy phrases that are not informative.
Title page. The following information, centered on the page:
TITLE OF PAPER
A Research Term Paper
by
Your Name
Submitted to
Dr. Douglas Spence
in partial fulfillment of the requirements for
NTSC 4311. History and Philosophy of Science
Month date, year (e.g., November 29, 2022)
ABSTRACT
The abstract is a short section that summarizes the major elements of the paper. An abstract is typically written as a single paragraph. In your “review”-type paper, your abstract should contain, but not be limited to, a statement of objectives, a statement of why the subject is of potential importance to the field of study, a short overview of any interesting aspects of the subject addressed by the paper, and any particular important conclusions drawn from the study. Although readers see the abstract first, it is easiest to write it last, once you have essentially completed your paper. Writing a good abstract is, surprisingly, one of the more difficult aspects of writing a paper. One way to write an abstract is to start with a list of all the important points covered in each section of the paper. Like a good title, a good abstract is both informative and brief. Further, a good abstract stands on its own, conveying all the essential information to the reader. An abstract is an absolutely essential component of every scientific paper, and your paper must include one for full consideration in grading.
Abstract page. The abstract page follows the title page, and is also not paginated. It is usually of the following format, with the label ABSTRACT, title of paper, and your name centered at the top, and the body of the abstract below as a paragraph:
ABSTRACT
Title of Paper
Your name
The body of the abstract is typed underneath. The abstract is the only part of the text of the paper in which it is acceptable to type single-spaced, although double-spaced is still preferred. Even if double-spaced, the abstract should still be less than one page in length.
BODY OF PAPER
The body of the paper, of course, contains the bulk of your work. The typical experimental paper has a rather standard format (Introduction, Materials and Methods, Results, Discussion, Conclusion), but it is unlikely you will be writing an experimental paper. The “review” paper of the type most of you will be writing, however, has a much less standard structure resulting from the very different topics that can be covered. Thus, while there are still several components that must be included in the body of the paper, much of the organization, structure, and sectioning you will need to devise for yourself.
The first page of the body (headed “Introduction”) is page 1 of your paper. The title page and abstract page are not numbered, nor counted among the numbered pages.
INTRODUCTION
The section that is standard for the body of all such papers is the “Introduction.” Structurally, the first page of the body of the paper should look something like this, with title, author, and INTRODUCTION centered at the top of the page:
Title of Paper
Your Name
INTRODUCTION
The introduction sets the stage for your study. It generally places your paper in a broad historical, philosophical, or scientific context and gives readers enough information to appreciate your objectives. The introduction accomplishes three tasks: (1) It introduces the subject, (2) it explains your rationale for choosing the topic, and (3) it states your main thesis, questions, and objectives. Thus you, as a writer, must have a firm grasp of the aims, principal findings, and relevance of your research. The introduction allows you to sketch out a framework for your study, orient your readers, and prepare them for what follows. Explain the rationale for the study and your major objectives. Why is this subject important? Will you be giving a comprehensive summary or one that is more limited? How does your work fit in with what is already known? What special aspect or problem does your study address? What new information have you tried to acquire? In other words, why are you writing the paper?
In general, the introduction section is not very long, perhaps several paragraphs or a couple of pages at most. In most instances, the last paragraph of the introduction states the purpose(s) of the paper. End the Introduction with a clear statement of the question you will address or the main point you wish to convey to the reader.
Subsequent sections
Beyond the Introduction, in review papers such as what you are likely to write the section headings are determined entirely by the details of your study, but they are necessary. Sectioning subdivides and gives order to an otherwise unwieldy amount of material. The rule here is: Use section headings frequently to divide your paper by obvious topics. A reader should be able to flip through the paper quickly, getting a general idea of its organization and the major topics that you cover simply by looking at the section headings. When inserting section headings, use the same format as for the abstract and introduction, for example, centered on the page in all upper case letters:
SECTION HEADING
Once you have completed the body of your paper, you need to summarize your main points. Thus the last section heading of your paper is:
CONCLUSION
The conclusion is usually fairly short, perhaps as short as a paragraph and rarely more than two or three, but its brevity belies its importance. Despite the importance of an effective Conclusion section, it often gets the least attention from beginning writers of a review paper. By the time they reach this point, most students are worn out and think they have nothing more to say. Nevertheless, the Conclusion section consolidates and strengthens the relationships, patterns, and arguments you have been building in the body of the paper. A good conclusion should more than merely summarize; it must, well, conclude something. Assuming you have adequately addressed the topic, now you must answer such questions as, what is the significance of everything you have just written? What issues or points still must be resolved? Still, avoid bringing up complex questions or issues that you cannot fully address. You do not want to leave your readers with a sense of incompleteness or hanging in midair. On the contrary, you want to tie up loose ends and finish with a satisfying sense of closure. Above all, try to leave the reader with an appreciation of having learned something that was worthwhile.
LITERATURE CITED
Following the Conclusion (the last section of the text of the paper) is the section listing all the source materials cited in the body of the text. What usually appears in scientific papers is called a Literature Cited, which contains only the sources that were cited (referred to) in the text, as opposed to a Bibliography, which contains all sources that were consulted and used by the author, even if they were not actually cited as a source in the text (a bibliography is more standard in the humanities). The Literature Cited section is also commonly called References.
The Literature Cited section begins on a new page following the body of the paper, but the pagination continues.
After typing the main body of the paper, you may be tempted to race through the Literature Cited, assuming that no one looks at this part. Do not underestimate the importance of a full and meticulously prepared Literature Cited section. I pay close attention to the literature you have cited, not only in the number of sources, but in their quality, also. This whole assignment is, after all, a research paper. I expect you to have carried out a significant amount of research, and it be reflected in your Literature Cited.
How many citations are considered an indicator of “sufficient” or “thorough” research? The answer varies somewhat depending on the nature of the topic, but a good rule of thumb for a standard review paper is this: There should be approximately as many literature sources cited as there are pages in the research paper. For example, a review paper with 15 pages of text should reference approximately 15 sources. Half that many would be considered an indicator of poor or insufficient research.
THE “LITERATURE”: HOW TO FIND IT, HOW TO USE IT
Writing a good review paper requires that you immerse yourself in the relevant literature. All research endeavors, including your own, acquire their fullest meaning and significance when viewed in the broader context of what other researchers – scientists, historians, etc. – past and present, have thought and done. Therefore, to become a competent scientist, both as a researcher and writer, you will need to develop competent skills in information-literacy. You will need to know how to locate the scholarly work of others, how to evaluate these sources critically, and how to incorporate this information effectively into your own work. Use the guidelines below to help you in searching, sorting, critiquing, citing, and listing the literature.
1. Understand the difference between primary and secondary sources. Primary sources are the works produced by the contemporary participants. In the sciences, primary sources are reports of original findings and ideas by the scientist(s) who conducted the work. Today, these most commonly take the form of peer-reviewed research papers in scholarly journals and are directed toward a scholarly audience. Thousands of scientific journals are published around the world. Some, such as Nature (U.K.) and Science (U.S.), report findings from all branches of the sciences; others are focused more narrowly within given disciplines. Other primary sources in the sciences include conference papers, dissertations, and technical reports from academic, governmental, or private entities. Today, it is rare that original scientific ideas and findings are initially reported in a full-length book. In the past, however, that was quite common. Thus, such seminal books in science such as Ptolemy’s Almagest, Copernicus’s De Revolutionibus, Newton’s Principia Mathematica, and Darwin’s On the Origin of Species, to name just a few of the most famous, qualify as primary sources. In any case, it is indispensable that you make the fullest use of whatever primary sources are available for your paper. I look hard at your Literature Cited for listings of primary sources. So, if your paper is about how Copernicus developed his heliocentric model of the solar system, you had better make use of De Revolutionibus. Similarly, if you are reporting on how the structure of DNA was determined, you need to consult Watson and Crick’s paper in Nature (and those of related contemporary researchers such as Pauling, Wilkins, and Franklin). Many of these are now available online in the public domain. Interlibrary loan can obtain materials our library does not have.
Secondary sources are works that are based on or derived from primary sources. Some are quite general, even introductory, written for readers who initially have little knowledge of the subject. Others are more detailed and technical, written for a more specialized audience. Types of secondary sources include scholarly books (“monographs”) and review papers (your own review paper would constitute a secondary source) that summarize and interpret the primary literature in a given subject area.
2. Getting started. Before plunging into the specialized primary literature on your topic, make sure you have a solid background and some sense of your aims and scope. Thus you might want to begin with some general secondary sources – even knowing that they may not be the types of sources you will actually cite in your paper – and work your way steadily through the more specialized secondary literature before arriving at primary sources. Excellent beginning or introductory secondary sources include:
Specialized encyclopedias provide brief, introductory surveys and usually contain additional references. General knowledge encyclopedias, in contrast, are not regarded as sufficiently authoritative to warrant citing and are not acceptable as sources; this goes for Wikipedia and other generalized websites (also see below).
Popular science magazines provide accessible introductions to fairly specialized topics. Their articles provide up-to-date overviews of particular subjects and also usually contain a list of additional references. Excellent popular science magazines include American Scientist and Scientific American.
Review papers are excellent in making the transition from the general to the specialized. They provide some historical perspective, summarize the contributions of influential researchers, and provide a sense of the important issues being addressed. Published review papers are also excellent models to consult for organization, formatting, and style while preparing your own paper.
3. Use the Literature Cited sections of relevant secondary and primary sources. One of the most efficient ways to expand your own list of sources is to take advantage of the literature that is referenced in primary and secondary sources. General secondary sources such as scientific encyclopedias may list only a few major, often equally general works, but review papers and primary refereed journal articles usually have lengthy Literature Cited sections which themselves can be a rich source of additional material that you can consult. And remember: The more recent the source, the more, and the more recent, the literature it provides for you.
4. Keep careful records. You will understand the importance of keeping records only once you suffer the consequences of not doing it. Keep a record of all sources you consult. It is a good idea to write out complete bibliographic entries of all sources as soon as you see them, and keep them in your file.
5. Allow ample time. It is important that you start your research as soon as possible, and it is easy to underestimate how much time it takes to do a thorough literature search. Successful library research is not simply a matter of accumulating many references as quickly as possible – this will make you feel overwhelmed. Stop at intervals to read or at least skim your best sources, and use them to help you refine your purpose and scope so that your search becomes more focused and specific. Of course, it is rarely necessary to read every word of a source – you don’t have to read De Revolutionibus cover-to-cover like a novel. Make intensive use of the table of contents, indexes, and section headings to guide you quickly to parts of the material that are relevant.
6. Proper and improper use of the Internet. Perhaps nothing has left faculty more slack-jawed perplexed than the totality with which this generation of students has thrown itself over to an unshakeable, unquestioning faith that the Internet is not just everything, it is the only thing. The Internet certainly contains a vast array of information, some of which is unobtainable in print sources, but on the whole the Internet has actually had a negative effect both on the ability of students to learn how to conduct research and the quality of the research conducted. The vast majority of easily accessible information on the Internet is, at best, secondary and, more common, a tertiary mish-mash, and cannot be relied on as scholarly research material. At best, the Internet can be used to find real scholarly research materials, but should not be used as scholarly research material.
DOCUMENTING YOUR PAPER
Citing Sources in the Text
Acknowledge the source of all material that is not your own. The text of a research paper contains numerous citations, or references to the published studies of other authors. Careful documentation, or acknowledgement of the work of others, is essential to good scholarly writing. Material that merits citation includes not only direct quotations (for qualifications about using quotations, see below), but also all information, findings, and ideas that stem from the work of someone else.
How much citation is too much, and how little is not enough? There is not an exact line between these two extremes, but students have a way of landing on one or the other. A general rule is that if the information you are presenting is a general synthesis from several sources, it is sufficient to provide the citations at least at the end of each paragraph, but if the information is unique to one source, then cite that source immediately as needed. Erring on the side of overcitation is considered the lesser error. Two common examples, however, of overcitation are:
1. Providing a citation after every sentence even if it is a citation of the same source, over and over again. In that case, hold the citation to the end of the paragraph or until the last instance in which that source is used, before a different source is invoked. It is then implicit that the citation covers all the information preceding it in that paragraph. This is the standard rule for citations in scientific journal articles.
2. Citations that include a long list of extraneous sources that were probably not actually consulted in depth but give the effect of “showing off.” Conversely, it is not necessary to cite sources for information regarded as common knowledge in a particular field. Occasionally, one sees a combination of these two types, overcitation of common knowledge that just makes the eyes roll. Example: “Antibiotics proved to be one of the miracle drugs of the twentieth century (1, 2, 4, 5, 7, 9, 10, 11, 14, 16, 18, 19, 21).”
Use quotations sparingly. Many writers tend to resort to lengthy quotations to cover the material for them or simply to pad the length of the paper. They often construct whole sections around a series of quotations, even whole block quotations, stringing them together with only a few introductory sentences or scattered phrases of their own. I have seen papers in which as much as 90 percent of some sections was directly quoted, often blocked, material. Quotations like these do not enhance the text. Rather, they detract from it, suggesting that the writer is either too inexperienced, short of time, or lazy to write their own work.
Writers should use quoted material sparingly and only when using truly significant passages, relying instead on careful, concise paraphrases or summaries, especially in scientific papers. There is a significant difference between the way quotations are used in humanities (history, literary studies, etc.) papers and in scientific papers. In humanities papers, a historical person’s letters, speeches, or other documents very often is the evidence that must be invoked to support the author’s points; in scientific papers, this is much less the case, as the evidence is regarded as being inherent in nature, and the work being cited is itself simply reporting the evidence.
Cite sources using a conventional format. Citation formats vary from one academic field to another. Unlike writers in the humanities, scientists rarely use footnotes to acknowledge sources. Instead, they typically insert citations within parentheses in the text. The two most common such formats are:
1. “Author-year” system. Cite each reference by giving the name(s) of the author(s) followed by the year in which the material was published. If two or more sources from the same author have the same publication year, specify them by placing a, b, etc., after the date.
Example. When the author’s name appears as part of the sentence: “Fischer (1971a) reported that stomatal aperture varies in a near-linear fashion with temperature . . .”
Example. When the author’s name is not part of the sentence but enclosed with the date of publication in parentheses: “The relative merits of each type of tissue stain have long been a subject of debate. (Glinka and Meidner, 1968; Fischer, 1971a,b).”
2. “Number” system. References in the Literature Cited are numbered sequentially, usually alphabetically by (first) author, and are cited in the text by the appropriate reference number in parentheses.
Example. Extreme variability in guard cell stomatal response has frustrated many researchers (8, 9, 12)
The Literature Cited
Use a conventional format for listing your sources. As with in-text citations, scientific journals vary with respect to the format used for the Literature Cited section, and in general, the style in which the entries are typed may differ significantly from styles that are common in the humanities (such as the Chicago Manual of Style or MLA Style Book). In practice, I care little about precisely which type of bibliographic format you use, so long as you provide complete bibliographic information and use whichever style you choose consistently throughout. That said, here are some examples comparing the standard “scientific” format and standard “humanities” format for listing sources:
“Scientific” format. With minor differences, this format is fairly standard in most of the biological and chemical journals with which I am familiar. I recommend that you select a standard journal in your specialty and follow its style.
Journal articles. Author(s) with first initials only; date of publication with or without parentheses; title of article with only the first word and any proper nouns capitalized; title of journal, either in italics when using a “print”-looking font like this or underlined when using a “typewriter”-looking font like this; volume and page numbers. Examples:
Spence, R.D. (1987). The problem of variability in stomatal responses, particularly aperture variance, to environmental and experimental conditions. The New Phytologist, 107: 303-315.
Wu, H., W.M. Childress, R.D. Spence and J Ren. (1996). An integrated simulation model for a semi-arid agroecosystem in the Loess Plateau of northwestern China. Agricultural Systems, 52:83-111.
Books. Author(s); date of publication (with or without parentheses); title of book, with every “important” word capitalized, and either italicized or underlined; edition number if applicable; publisher; city and state. Examples:
Darwin, C.R. (1859). On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection. Reissue by Gramercy Books, Random House, Avenel, New Jersey.
Nobel, P.S. (1999). Physicochemical and Environmental Plant Physiology. Second edition. Academic Press, San Diego, California.
Chapters within (usually edited) books. Author(s) of chapter, date of publication (with or without parentheses); title of chapter, “in” editor(s), title of book either italicized or underlined; edition number if applicable; publisher; city; state, page numbers of chapter. Example:
Sharpe, P.J.H., H. Wu and R.D. Spence (1987) Stomatal mechanics. In Stomatal Function, E. Zeiger, G. Farquhar, and I.R. Cowan, eds., Stanford University Press, Stanford, California, pp. 91-114.
“Humanities” format. Again, with minor differences, these formats are fairly standard in the humanities.
Journal articles. Author with full name as published; title of article with all important words capitalized and within quotation marks; title of journal italicized or underlined; volume number usually in Roman numerals, issue number (month or quarter and year of issue in parentheses), page numbers. Example:
Spence, Richard Douglas. “Samuel Donelson: The Young Andrew Jackson’s Best Friend.” Tennessee Historical Quarterly, vol. LXIX, no. 2 (Summer 2010), pp. 106-123.
Book. Author with full published name; title with all important words capitalized in italicized or underlined; city of publication followed by colon (:), publisher, date of publication. Example:
Spence, Richard Douglas. Andrew Jackson Donelson: Jacksonian and Unionist. Nashville: Vanderbilt University Press, 2017.
Chapter in a (usually edited) book. Author with full published name; title with all important words capitalized and in quotation marks; page numbers; editor(s); title of book italicized or underlined; city of publication followed by colon (:), publisher, date of publication. Example:
Kuhn, Thomas S. “Objectivity, Value Judgment, and Theory Choice,” pp. 102-118. Martin Curd and J.A. Cover, eds. Philosophy of Science. The Central Issues. New York: W.W. Norton & Company, 1998.
SUMMARY OF WHAT IS VITAL FOR YOUR PAPER:
Your paper should be organized structurally with the following components:
Title Page
Abstract
Introduction (beginning the body of the paper, 12-14 pages in length overall)
Interior section headings as appropriate.
Citations of sources in the text
Conclusion
Literature Cited
In general, before I even begin to read the actual text of your paper, I flip through the paper to make sure all these components are there. The absence of any one of these required components is a sufficient weakness to result in the loss of a letter grade off the top; multiple omissions can accumulate multiple letter grade deductions.
Acknowledgements
For more detailed information, it is worthwhile to refer to:
McMillan, Victoria E. Writing Papers in the Biological Sciences. Third edition. Boston: Bedford’s/St. Martin’s Press, 2001.
Last Completed Projects
| topic title | academic level | Writer | delivered |
|---|
