Are you convinced of Liu’s argument? Why or why not?

For this response, please reflect on Catherine Liu’s Virtue Hoarders: The Case against the Professional Managerial Class.

While this is a more freeform assignment, I would still like to see you break your reflection into a series of discrete paragraphs rather than one long paragraphs. I would like to see you quote directly from the (twice per paragraph is ideal) to support whatever claims you make.

Please use the following questions only as a guide. Rather than structuring your essay as a response to one or more of these questions specific questions, I’m more interested in having you simply respond to the text while thinking about these questions:

Are you convinced of Liu’s argument? Why or why not?
Can you think of an example of PMC virtue hoarding that Liu doesn’t mention?
Can you think of a contemporary group or example that either supports or contradicts Liu’s argument?
Is Liu’s argument important or helpful given the context of contemporary politics and social strife?
What can we do with Liu’s argument?

Last Completed Projects