Civil liability for business

Read the following scenarios and answer the questions that follow. Answers must demonstrate critical thinking and concepts from the course. Any outside resources must be cited and referenced. This assignment should be at least one page in content.

Scenario #1
“Huge selection of Guernsey sweaters,” reads a newspaper ad from Stuffed Shirt, a clothing retailer. “Regularly $135, today only $65.” Waldo arrives at Stuffed Shirt at 4:00 that afternoon, but the shop clerk says there are no more sweaters. He shows Waldo a newly arrived Shetland sweater that sells for $145. Waldo sues, claiming breach of contract and violation of a consumer protection statute. Who will prevail?
(a) Waldo will win the breach of contract suit and the consumer protection suit.
(b) Waldo will lose the breach of contract suit but might win the consumer protection suit.
(c) Waldo will lose the consumer protection suit but should win the breach of contract suit.
(d) Waldo will win the consumer protection suit only if he wins the contract case. (e) Waldo will lose both the breach of contract suit and the consumer protection suit.

Strategy: Waldo assumes that he is accepting the store’s offer. But did Stuffed Shirt make an offer? Does the consumer protection statute help him?

Scenario #2
An aunt saw her eight-year-old nephew enter the room, remarked what a nice boy he was, and said, “I would like to take care of him now.” She promptly wrote a note, promising to pay the boy $3,000 upon her death. Her estate refused to pay. Is it obligated to do so?

Strategy: A contract is enforceable only if the parties have given consideration. The consideration might be an act or a forbearance. Did the nephew give consideration?

Scenario #3
McElroy owned 104 acres worth about $230,000. He got into financial difficulties and approached Grisham, asking to borrow $100,000. Grisham refused, but ultimately the two reached this agreement: McElroy would sell Grisham his property for $80,000, and the contract would include a clause allowing McElroy to repurchase the land within two years for $120,000. McElroy later claimed the con-tract was void. Is he right?

Strategy: Loans involving usury do not always include a clearly visible interest rate. You may have to do some simple math to see the interest being charged. McElroy wanted to borrow $100,000, but instead sold his property, with the right to repurchase. If he did repurchase, how much interest would he have effectively paid?

Scenario #4
Andreini’s nerve problem diminished the use of his hands. Dr. Beck operated, but the problem grew worse. A nurse told the patient that Beck might have committed a serious error that exacerbated the problem. Andreini returned for a second operation, which Beck assured him would correct the problem. But after Andreini had been placed in a surgical gown, shaved, and prepared for surgery, the doctor insisted that he sign a release relieving Beck of liability for the first operation. Andreini did not want to sign it, but Beck refused to operate until he did. Later, Andreini sued Beck for malpractice. A trial court dismissed Andreini’s suit based on the release. You are on the appeals court. Will you affirm the dismissal or reverse?

Strategy: Andreini is claiming physical duress. Did Beck act improperly in demanding a release? Did Andreini have a realistic alternative?
Add submission

Last Completed Projects

topic title academic level Writer delivered