The Path Making Essay

In “States,” Said uses photos-with-text to make visible the invisible, stateless, diasporic Palestinian community. Reading Response 2 reflected on the depth and care with which he reads the opening photograph, “Tripoli, Badawi camp, May 1983.” This descriptive lingering is instructive for us. The writing handbook They Say/I Say: The Moves that Matter in Academic Writing warns new writers against something called “hit-and-run” quotations—that is, pieces of evidence left “dangling” without any explanation (41). Said teaches us rather to “drive up” next to a visual finding and to stay with it, examine it, question it, speculate about it, and interpret it.

This assignment invites you to compose a Said-like reading of a series of images, but from a different angle. Using “fragments, memories, disjointed scenes, [and] intimate particulars,” Said teaches the reader what to see in and across the photos based on his lived expertise (521). You will do something quite different: trace what you do not know, can’t yet make sense of, or what confounds you, by tracking details, complexities, and contradictions within and across a series of visual artifacts from your primary source materials or on the topic of your inquiry. There is room within this tracking for your own story and knowledges, of course, but your project is not to make a claim. Your project is to wander further into your question and to begin to feel for footholds—“reading” toward what to ask or look for and how, next.

Your artifacts can be photos that you took at a field site, found images, excerpts from an archive, screenshots, something else, or some combination of these. Choose artifacts that you know will not be easily or readily understood by others. Sequence them in a way that pronounces the mystery for you. Tell us what to see, where to look. Hold onto the sense that the artifacts cannot speak for themselves; you must speak for them. (1100 words)

Last Completed Projects

topic title academic level Writer delivered