Reply directly to this prompt in 100+words. Afterward, reply to one of your classmates in 100+ words. Due Thursday 11:59pm. When replying to your classmate, if you disagree, do so politely and with conviction. If you agree with the classmate you are replying to, do more than simply state that you agree (e.g. don’t just say “Wow, you brought up a great point! I think you put the point so nicely!”) Instead, use the Yes-and formula, such as in “Yes I agree with you, and __[here is X thing, where X thing is also applicable to your point, further proves your point, or is something to consider]__.”
Prompt:
In his paper, James Rachels argues against moral relativism. He particularly argues that accepting moral relativism will lead to bad consequences. He says that if we accepted moral relativism:
we would also be stopped from criticizing other, less benign practices. Suppose a society waged war on its neighbors for the purpose of taking slaves. Or suppose a society was violently anti-Semitic and its leaders set out to destroy the Jews. Cultural Relativism would preclude us from saying that either of these practices was wrong. We would not even be able to say that a society tolerant of Jews is better than the anti- Semitic society, for that would imply some sort of transcultural standard of comparison. The failure to condemn these practices does not seem enlightened; on the contrary, slavery and anti-Semitism seem wrong wherever they occur. Nevertheless, if we took Cultural Relativism seriously, we would have to regard these social practices as also immune from criticism.
1) What is moral relativism? Why would accepting moral relativism require us to not criticize other cultures?
2) Do you agree with Rachels that we should reject moral relativism? Why or why not?o
Last Completed Projects
| topic title | academic level | Writer | delivered |
|---|
